Millennials vs. Boomers: Who Really Had It Harder Buying a Home? Here's the San Diego Math
Boomers spent 36% of income on housing at 30 vs. 27% for millennials, until 2022. In San Diego, a median home now takes about 72% of median income.
Short answer: Nationally, millennials actually had it easier than baby boomers, until 2022. At age 30, older millennials spent about 27% of their income on housing, compared with about 36% for boomers, according to Redfin's November 2026 analysis. But millennials who bought after rates rose above 6% have spent up to 35% of their income, while boomers spent about 25% at the same age. In San Diego, the gap is far wider: buying the area's median-priced home in October 2026 would take roughly 72% of the county's median household income under Redfin's method.
So both sides of the family argument at Thanksgiving are partly right.
Did boomers really have it harder?
At first, yes, by Redfin's numbers.
Boomers faced mortgage rates that peaked above 16% in 1981. Even with lower home prices, Redfin estimates boomers spent:
- Over 60% of their income on housing in their early 20s
- About 40% in their late 20s
- About 36% at age 30
- About 26% in their late 30s
Millennials who bought before the pandemic caught a break. Rates fell below 3% in 2021, and at age 30, older millennials spent about 27% of income on housing.
So what changed in 2022?
Rates and prices both jumped. Mortgage rates went from under 3% in 2021 to nearly 7% by late 2022, and home prices kept climbing.
That flipped the math for anyone who bought afterward:
| Measure | Older millennials | Boomers |
|---|---|---|
| Share of income at age 30 | About 27% | About 36% |
| Share of income after 2022 (same age) | Up to 35% | About 25% |
| Typical monthly payment, ages 40–44 (today's dollars) | About $3,000 | About $1,986 |
| Household income at about age 37 | About $100,000 | About $88,000 |
Millennials earn more than boomers did at the same age, but not enough to cover the much bigger payment.
Gen Z has it harder still. Redfin estimates the typical home has taken roughly 40% to 60% of Gen Z's income since they reached homebuying age.
How does it feel to the people who own?
Redfin's May 2026 survey shows the split:
- 76% of boomer homeowners say they can easily afford their payment
- 53% of millennial homeowners say the same
- Among people unlikely to move soon, 43% of millennials blame high home prices, compared with 31% of boomers
Boomers also benefited from refinancing as rates fell over the decades, while their home values rose. That's a big reason so many are wealthy in real estate today.
What does it look like in San Diego?
Redfin's generational study is national. Here's what happens when we apply its method to San Diego.
| Input | San Diego, fall 2026 |
|---|---|
| Median sale price (San Diego metro, October 2026, Redfin) | $921,759 |
| Down payment (20%) | $184,352 |
| Mortgage rate (weekly average in early November, as cited by Redfin) | 7.18% |
| Monthly principal and interest | About $4,995 |
| Taxes and insurance (Redfin's assumptions: 0.5% and 1.25% of price a year) | About $1,344 |
| Total monthly payment | About $6,340 |
| Median household income (San Diego County, Census 2020–2024) | $106,268 a year, about $8,856 a month |
| Share of income | About 72% |
That's roughly double the 36% boomers faced at 30, even before counting saving up a $184,000 down payment.
For comparison: the same home at a 3% rate would take about 50% of the median income, and at 6%, about 65%. Lower rates help, but in San Diego they don't close the gap alone.
This is our own illustration using Redfin's method and public data, not a Redfin figure. Real payments vary by home, rate, taxes, insurance and down payment, and many San Diego buyers have higher incomes or buy below the median.
So how are younger San Diegans buying at all?
From what our team sees, buyers are getting creative:
- Starting smaller or farther out, then moving up with the equity
- Negotiating seller credits and rate buydowns, which are common right now. See How to Ask for a Seller Credit.
- Considering condos, where buyers currently have strong leverage. In September, San Diego had about 81% more condo sellers than buyers, according to Redfin.
- Using family help or down payment assistance
- Knowing the real payment before shopping. See Why the Mortgage Calculator Lied to You.
Is there any good news?
Some. Redfin's economists say a realistic goal is a return to 2018–2019 housing costs, when the typical U.S. buyer spent about 30% of income on housing. Softening prices in some areas could help get there sooner.
In San Diego, prices were still up 3.7% from a year earlier in October, so local relief is likely to come slowly. But buyers here currently have more negotiating power than they've had in years.
Frequently asked questions
Did millennials or boomers pay more for housing?
It depends on when they bought. At age 30, boomers spent about 36% of income on housing and older millennials about 27%. But millennials who bought after 2022 have spent up to 35%, versus about 25% for boomers at the same age (Redfin, November 2026).
What share of income does a San Diego home take?
By our calculation using Redfin's method, the San Diego metro's October 2026 median sale price of $921,759 would take about 72% of San Diego County's median household income at a 7.18% mortgage rate with 20% down.
What share of income is considered affordable for housing?
A common guideline is about 30% of gross income. Redfin's economists point to the 2018–2019 level, when the typical U.S. buyer spent about 30% of income on housing, as a realistic goal.
Key takeaways
- Boomers had it harder at 30 (about 36% of income vs. 27% for older millennials).
- Since 2022, millennials have had it harder, spending up to 35% of income compared with about 25% for boomers at the same age.
- In San Diego, the median home takes about 72% of median household income at early-November rates, by our calculation using Redfin's method.
- Strategy matters more than timing: credits, buydowns, condos and stepping-stone homes are how many buyers are getting in.
Are you a first-time buyer trying to make San Diego work? Talk to our team, or join our San Diego Homebuyer Class.
Cover photo: Couple moving into a new home on Unsplash.
Sources
- The Generational Housing Divide: Millennials Had It Better Than Baby Boomers–Until the Pandemic Changed the Math (Redfin, 2026-11-12)
- October Marks the First Month in 3 Years With a Decline in U.S. Home-Sale Prices (Redfin, 2026-11-10)
- For Every Condo Buyer in the U.S., There Are More Than Two Sellers (Redfin, 2026-11-09)
- QuickFacts: San Diego County, California (median household income, 2020–2024) (U.S. Census Bureau)
Disclaimer: Educational purposes only. The GreenHouse Group Inc. (CA DRE #01859042 | NMLS #366847). We are real estate and mortgage professionals, not CPAs, tax advisors or attorneys. This content is not individualized real estate, financial, tax, legal or lending advice. Generational figures are national estimates from the cited Redfin analysis. The San Diego payment example is our own illustration using public data and assumed tax and insurance rates, not a quote or loan offer. Rates, prices and incomes change. The GreenHouse Group is not affiliated with Redfin.
